Casey Wolfe is a horndog. He has no interest in a serious relationship. Attractive and honest, he has no shortage of female companions. Sheridan Christian is new to Hope. She left behind her life in NYC after her fiancé cheated on her. Not given to one-night stands, she nonetheless agrees to spend the night with Casey, but she sneaks out before he wakes up to save herself some embarrassment. That should be that, except Casey cannot forget her. He wants more from a woman for the first time since he was eighteen. Sheridan’s anxiety, Casey’s past, and a jealous ex- conspire to keep these two apart.